Short answer: PliimPRO costs $22 for a lifetime license or comes with Setapp, runs on macOS 10.15 or later, and you turn it on with a click. Curtainly is free during the beta and turns on by itself for supported meeting apps, but needs macOS 26 on Apple silicon.

Side by side

CurtainlyPliimPROSource
PriceFree during the beta$22 lifetime (launch promo) for 1 computer, or with a Setapp membership (from $14.99 a month)Curtainly, Pliim, Setapp
macOSmacOS 26 or later, Apple siliconmacOS 10.15 or laterCurtainly, Pliim, Setapp
macOS 26 supportYesNot statedCurtainly, Pliim
How it turns onBy itself for supported meeting apps; ⌃⌥C for anything elseOne click, or the ⌥-click shortcutCurtainly, Pliim
DesktopWallpaper and icons hidden (beta)Hides desktop icons, changes the wallpaperCurtainly, Pliim
DockAuto-hide on (beta)Not listedCurtainly, Pliim
NotificationsDo Not Disturb on (beta)Disables notificationsCurtainly, Pliim
SoundAlert sounds muted (beta)Mutes speakersCurtainly, Pliim
AirDrop receivingOff (beta)Not listedCurtainly, Pliim
AppsApps you list, plus apps you point at (beta)Hides active appsCurtainly, Pliim
MicrophoneNot listedMute with ⌘⇧MCurtainly, Pliim
When it turns offWhat it changed goes back, and Curtainly tells you if a part didn't.Setapp page says everything goes back to normalCurtainly, Setapp
Shows its statusA pill under the notch counts each part as it's hiddenNot statedCurtainly

Curtainly's feature list is labelled "Design preview — beta" on its site, so every Curtainly feature above is a beta feature.

When to pick Pliim instead

  • Your Mac runs a macOS older than 26 (PliimPRO lists 10.15 or later). Curtainly needs macOS 26 and Apple silicon.
  • You already pay for Setapp. PliimPRO is included.
  • You want a mic mute shortcut in the same app.
  • You'd rather decide each time with one click than have an app turn on for you.
  • You want something open source. Pliim's site says the original open-source Pliim stays free.

When Curtainly fits better

  • You forget to turn things on before a call. Curtainly turns on by itself for supported meeting apps.
  • You don't want to pay while it's in beta.
  • You want the Dock and AirDrop requests handled too.

Curtainly's limitations

  • It can't hide menu-bar apps, and macOS won't let it hide some other apps either.
  • It doesn't hide what's inside the window you share, like browser tabs, chat panes or the file you're presenting.
  • The app you're sharing from stays. If that's a browser, its other windows stay too.
  • The Dock still slides in if your pointer reaches the screen edge.
  • Time-sensitive notifications can still get through Do Not Disturb.
  • It can't see every share, such as a single browser tab. For those you press ⌃⌥C.
  • It's in beta, free, with a waitlist, and runs only on macOS 26 or later on Apple silicon.

Questions

Does Pliim work on macOS 26? Pliim's site and its Setapp page say macOS 10.15 or later and don't mention macOS 26.

Does Pliim turn on by itself? Its site describes turning it on with one click or an ⌥-click shortcut, and doesn't mention starting by itself.

Join the Curtainly waitlist

Sources